Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 

I TRACED

Sun Apr 15, 2007, 1:58 AM
YES, I traced.

And I've been such an idiot not to frikin yelling it out earlier. SUCH an IDIOT. It's really hard to even give ANY motivation for it. And I will not, it would only make this entry lamer and take away from the actual point I want to make.

Here's the bottom line: I traced. I got attention for it. I kept doing it, and kept lying about it, and I got even more attention for it. And even when I could actually stop, I persisted, becoming quite ridiculous. Sure, I did remove the images, I did move on, 6 months ago even, but see, the problem is, it's really not about me anymore. A bunch of people forgave me quietly, but again, being forgiven or not is not the point, because hey, me tracing, that's not THAT big of a deal in the first place, right?

Hmm, except it is a big deal.

Why do so many Disney fanartists trace? Quite simply, BECAUSE so many OTHER Disney fanartists trace. Yes, it's understood, implied, that the work isn't REALLY our own. But after spending hours on the drawing it just FEELS like it's yours, because on this, it's very easy to behave childishly. Like a kid saying "mine!" when he's referring to a toy in the property of his kindergarden. Why? partially because he doesn't understand what property is. That is a problem in general, yes. And if you have any aspects of this you feel you don’t fully understand, you absolutely SHOULD go to :devsnapesgirl:'s tutorial on the matter, which is wonderfully written and only with the best feelings in mind, trust me. Here are links to that:
[link]
[link]
[link]

But the second part of why the kid says "mine!" is because he likes playing with the toy, and has been playing with it for a while, and because no one's bothered to tell him... "NO, this is NOT yours". And the more time passes the bigger a tantrum the kid will throw when he finally hears it's not his.

And see, because I understood this is why so many Disney fanartists trace (and what's more persist in doing it LOOOONG after they really need to in order to learn the basics of drawing, LONG after they are ready to try to be original, and me and them persist in this "lying" by keeping silent), cause of all that, I FINALLY understood all the implications of what I had done... the damage is, for the most part, completely irreparable.

It's really not that _I_ traced. Or that tracing is something no one else has ever done in their lives. Yes, a lot of artists do that out that way, whether at 6 or at 13 or at 18. But what I did VERY WRONG is that I gave tracing a pretty little shine that makes OTHER people go like "oooh, I wanna do that too!". And why is it BAD to trace? Well, because the longer you do it, and the more warmth and attention you get as a consequence of it, the HARDER it is to STOP. It's not like in real life, where if you trace, you at most show it to your parents or your friend next door, or your friend from school. they may like it, but really, their effect on you is INCOMPARABLE to the months, years, of constant support and exposure you can get for it on the internet. And you will find, when, IF, you want to start drawing original things, that they are not HALF as appreciated, because they aren’t quite as pretty as the Disney “clipart” ultimately, you’ve worked on before. And that is discouraging. ALL these things create a climate that PROMOTES unoriginality, lies, deceit. And this climate grows and grows, because ultimately, nothing all that bad happens to you. You do get in trouble for it, you do make people mad, but if you shut up about it, chances are you'll be able to go on just fine, if you shut out deviantart or the whole art community for a little while. It’s plainly what I did. And the spammers from 4chan absolutely cannot compare to the sort of hate mail those advocating for anti-art theft have received.

I may not have started the phenomenon, the anti-art theft community may have come on my page at a weird time in my personal life, and that caused me to react even stupider than I would have otherwise... Deviantart may not enforce the policy all the time. People may have understood how, gee, it's only fanart, even if it's a race or photomanipulation. "If disney doesn't care, why should other people?" The methods emplyed to get me to understand may have been too harsh. And many of you may not even care anymore.

But the reason why this whole drama has gotten SO BIG, is quite simply, me. What I did. How I reacted. And what's worst is that _I_ SINCERELY appreciate the harshness of those people who WERE against what I did, who DID harshly blame me for my actions. Because without them, I'd still be this HUGE link in this very unpretty deceitful chain, BLISSFULLY, IDIOTICALLY. Whatever questions I may have as to how they behaved, it pales completely under the FACT: they were telling THE TRUTH. I WAS NOT.

So please, I expect that most of my watchers received an e-mail from them recently linking to a comment I had randomly made about my tracing. DO NOT get pissed off at it. It's _THE FRIKIN TRUTH_. And I had yet to admit it publicly. So no, they're not trying to "destroy my reputation". They've only tried to put everyone in front of MY LIES. The reputation destruction... I did that myself :P

And no matter how much I shout it out from the rooftops now, I WILL NOT be able to fully clean up the mess I've made. *shrug* but I might as well make a statement to clear stuff up *shrug* It sure as heck took me long enough :/ And I was even too big of a chicken to come up with this thought myself. Making this, VERY necessary journal entry is soooo far from a big grand gesture of honesty, don't glorify it. It's cowardly that it's come so late, it's assholish that I've lied for so long. It's NOT something to admire. it's something to forgive.

  • Mood: Shame

Devious Comments

:iconshimimouse:
At least you've fessed up and are trying to make a clean start on your account. :hug: I'm happy for you.

I'm still keeping the Wicked pics of yours though (which I appriciant and adore) The poses may have been traced (I dunno if they were or not) but they're still Elphie and I know there aren't any like them.

--
m"900 years and I have never been slapped by someone's mother."
-9th Doctor
:iconrogue-of-the-night:
:hug:

--
*~-~-~-~-~*
Friendship is like peeing your pants,
Everyone can see it,
But only you can feel the true warmth :heart:
*~-~-~-~-~*
:icondisney-bubbles:
they were traced poses, yep. feel free to keep them, the damage to create them has already been done. long as you treat them as elaborate photomanipulations and don't credit them to me, I don't really care.
:iconchrislocksart:
It takes a lot for someone to do what you have just done. And you should be proud. So what if you traced? I don't feel theres anything I need to forgive you for. I mean sure, I haven't been the most active commenter on your gallery. Even if you did trace, your deviations always looked awesome! And that wasn't because of tracing that is because YOU made them that way.
Best of luck, Chris.

--
:skull: Gallery! :skull:
:icontscabo:
Im not gonna bother.. But I think tracing is awesome to use when you learn.
And Ive seen alot worse than your little tracing. I still think youre awesome, and your Beauty and the Beast-project still rocks my socks. <3
:icondisney-bubbles:
yes, but see, that's irrelevant. I know what most people on my watch list have wanted to see is pretty pictures. how they were created, who they belonged to, it mattered less than the actual "product". The fact that I traced and I did for so long, and SO publically is bad because it's NOT just about me tracing. it's about many numerous artists who will be doing the same thing because I did and things turned out so well for me. and overall that leads to a GIGANTIC mess.

I KNOW I can create pretty things, I know I can do decent manipulations and so on, and that a bit of the credit for that may be personal. but that doesn't make art. Deviantart, IS, a place for ART. And my behavior and the behavior of others like me makes it impossible for actual artists, who create original works, to learn and improve, because they get next to no attention what-so-ever, next to the dozens of disney/anime artists who trace and get a zillion page views... I hope you understand, the problem is my lying and the popularity and the understanding I got uhm... not doing anything GOOD OR NOBLE. FOR LYING. It makes others think it's really cool to lie like that about it, because people think your artwork is stunning if they think you made it 100%.

see, the guilt I have currently extends beyond my personal artwork. :/ and it SHOULD extend beyond it too.
:iconmistressraven1605:
Well it's good you got it out now. I wanted to believe that recent email was a lie, but I could plainly see it wasn't. It's good that your out of that now. I'm alittle angered by the fact you indeed traced. But I think I can forgive you for it, since your actually drawing now without the aid of a picture. I actually can't believe it's true (you tracing and all). When I first started reading this I want to say something mean, but after reading I realized I couldn't. I saw that you were another person to fall victim to the easy way out popularizing way of art that some people find their way into. It's something I can't get made about. I knew people who were like that. I could never hate them for it. And its the same for you, I can't hate you cause you did it, its just not me. And since you admitted it and appologized for it you can be forgiven. Yea sure it was a stupid thing, we all do stupid things, (me plenty) but we learn to move on from them. And I'm just glad your finally moving on from it. Sure it may take you a life time to gain you reputation back, but least people will know your not afraid to take blame for the wrong things you did. Things will get worse before they get better, but they will get better eventually. ;)

--
Check out my clubs -> ~Digimon-Clubi~AnimeArtClubi~Beautiful-Photos


My stock account -> ~Rave-Stock
:iconshimimouse:
Only my friends shall know the truth (cuz I kinda already told them) and thy are staying safely on only my computer. I'm a greedy pack rat that way :)

--
m"900 years and I have never been slapped by someone's mother."
-9th Doctor
:iconchrislocksart:
I understand that completely. And yeah, maybe lying wasn't the best way around it. If you took your own stock references for poses, theres nothing to be ashamed of. If however you used stocks from Da and didn't tell the artists, then thats a different matter. Seriously, the damage is done, you must feel terrible or w/e. But you've told everyone the truth NOW, now is better than not telling them at all. Sure the next few days isn't going to get better, and no doubt a lot of spam will come your way, but take it and move on and show us what you really can do!
I know I don't know you or anything, but if everything gets too much and you needa talk to someone, just note me ok. :)

--
:skull: Gallery! :skull:
:icondisney-bubbles:
awesome, no. useful, yeah. and a lot of people DO start out that way, irregardless of the age they do it at.

But see, I'm not saying "zomg, don't trace, it is EEEEVIL". I'm saying, I acted very very very badly because 1) I put it online, alllllll over the place. 2) I did not specify that the work WAS unoriginal 3) I ALLOWED people to believe that I had created the artwork completely, sometimes even lying to them flat out. 4) I encouraged other people to trace the same way, indirectly, but I DID.

Tracing is a fine way to learn, sure. But then you don't put hundreds of images "to learn" on the internet, the way I did, or at least you specify "look, this is a trace, I'm using it to learn how to color. I'm not good enough to draw my own work yet, does anyone have any tips?" because THAT way, there are no confusions. But I purposefully confused people, and thus made a gigantic liar out of myself.

Journal History

Site Map